Begin with place and purpose
Identify the site, its climate, surrounding streets, landscape, and existing buildings. Ask what the project is intended to do and who is expected to use it. A design cannot be evaluated fully without understanding the conditions it responds to.
Then look at movement. How do people arrive? Where are the entrances? Can someone find the path without assistance? How does the project connect to transit, sidewalks, bicycle routes, service access, and neighboring public spaces?
A project description should distinguish design intent from measured performance. A visual claim about openness or sustainability does not establish how a building operates after people move in.
Read the plan, section, and material choices
A plan shows how rooms and routes relate horizontally. A section helps explain height, daylight, vertical circulation, and the connection between levels. Elevations and details reveal how the building meets the street and how materials are assembled.
Materials should be considered at more than surface level. Ask how they weather, how they can be repaired, and whether the selected details fit the building’s use and maintenance capacity. The same material may perform differently depending on exposure and construction.
Look for flexibility. Can a space accommodate a new activity? Are service systems accessible for repair? Does the structure allow future adaptation without unnecessary demolition?
Evaluate what happens after occupancy
Post-occupancy evidence can reveal whether the design supports comfort, accessibility, energy performance, and intended use. Interviews, utility data, maintenance records, and observation each provide a different perspective.
Projects involve trade-offs. A strong study explains what was prioritized, what constraints shaped the decision, and what the team would reconsider. Honest reflection is more useful than claiming every project solved every problem.
Use this framework on buildings near you. A library, station, bridge, housing block, or renovated warehouse can show how design choices affect ordinary routines.
Questions to take to the site
- Who uses this place, and how do they arrive?
- What will require care or maintenance over time?
- How does this project connect to the surrounding neighborhood?